How One Fence in the Philippines Made It to Their Supreme Court

  • By Clean Cut Fence
  • 29 Mar, 2013

It's hard to believe that a fence would be important enough to be brought before a supreme court, but indeed,  the Filipino Supreme Court ruled on a fence this past week , ultimately determining the fate of a privacy fence  surrounding a school.

The local government in the city of Marikina, Philippines, created ordinances that established rules on fences in the city, including that all fences must be at least 80% see-through with gaps between and that no fence should be higher than one meter (approximately 3 feet).

The School Says No

 A private school found themselves on the end of an order to demolish their security fence to comply with the new height and visibility ordinances.

In addition, the city government told them to move the fence back six meters (nearly 20 feet) to provide more parking space!

The private school was able to secure an injunction, and as the case worked itself through the court system, more and more courts sided with the school. The city government continually appealed until finally, the case reached the Filipino Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court Agrees

In its own way, the Court gave the Marikina government a scathing commentary on their ordinances, ultimately siding with the school and putting an end to the case.

Their reasons for siding with the school included:

  • No justification for the height requirement.
  • Invasion of school privacy and no indication that a see through fence would have any positive impact on the security of the school or the city (in fact, the court agreed that a see-through fence would be less secure).
  • Moving the fence would cause the school to lose land, and the city government must pay them for that land in order to secure it.

The next time you look at your fence, imagine it becoming a federal case—it did in the Philippines, and the case for security fences was made clear!

By Kela Roth 09 Mar, 2017

Time to start planning those projects you have been dreaming of all winter long. Whether it is a new fence to add to your backyard living area or some maintenance on your existing fence. Now is the perfect time to start that project. In designing your fence there are several different options to choose from -- Aluminum and Custom Wood are two of the most popular fence types. However, plenty homeowners are perfectly satisfied with galvanized or the vinyl coated chain-link. The vinyl privacy is also a great option.

For those of you that have a wooden fence now is the perfect time to protect your investment by staining and sealing. This ensures that your investment will be well protected as well as adding a beautiful color to the fence.

By Kela Roth 26 Jul, 2016
More Posts
Share by: